National Center for Sustainability Reporting > Articles > Issues of Audit Committee ‘Knowledge and Experience’ in Social and Environmental Reporting Assurance

Issues of Audit Committee ‘Knowledge and Experience’ in Social and Environmental Reporting Assurance

Dewi Fitriasari – BiNus Business School, Bina Nusantara University, Indonesia
Claus Holm – Department of Economics and Business, Aarhus University, Denmark

How to secure the independence of external sustainability report assurors? This question arises from the understanding that the management of companies often have central roles in the processes of the assurance. In the case of financial reporting, the appointment of financial statement auditors and the audit performance are under the monitoring of the audit committees to ensure the independence. The implementation of this monitoring is made possible by regulations in stock exchanges.

The minimum quality of the implementation is set by the regulations through a defined scope of the works and the minimum ‘knowledge and experience’ that the members of audit committees must have. The opposite condition applies to sustainability reporting. Then, stakeholders are left with no choice. The stakeholders have to trust trust that the current ‘knowledge and experience’ of audit committees’ members in finance and accounting will help to ensure the independence of the assurors. An evaluation of 250 companies listed in the Fortune Global 500 Companies as per 2009 indicates that:

  1. the association between the current ‘knowledge and experience’ of audit committee members and their choices to appoint accountant as assurors even though the professional code of independence is familiar to audit committee members under the scheme of financial statement audit, and
  2. the association between the current ‘knowledge and experience’ of audit committees and other types of assurors, i.e. consultant assurors and individual assurors is weak even though these assurors declare their independence as required under sustainability report assurance.

Based on the evaluation, it is unlikely that the audit committee members are able to secure assuror independence by (1) executing their current knowledge and expertise in financial statement auditing to secure the general assuror independence as in financial statement audit, or (2) extending their knowledge and expertise to cover the specific assuror independence as needed in sustainability report assurance. Therefore, the members of the committees need to have specific ‘knowledge and experience’ in sustainability reporting and assurance before stakeholders can hope to depend on the committees to maintain the independence of the external assurors. But, will the members of the committees answer this urgent need?

Parts of this article are published by the Aarhus University Press, Aarhus, Denmark in 2011.

Upcoming schedule

No event found!

Program

GRI Standards Certified Training

The Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) is a non-governmental organization that develops and disseminates globally applicable voluntary Sustainability Reporting Guidelines. These guidelines has been developed through a multi-stakeholder process that incorporates the active participation of business, accountancy, investment, human rights, research and labour organizations from around the world.

Learn more

Updates

  • Why CSOs are key to value-led sustainability

    March 13, 2021

    Chief sustainability officers are helping to demonstrate why creating value from sustainability is an imperative for their organizations. In brief... View Article

  • NCSR ASRRAT 2020

    December 16, 2020

    The National Center for Sustainability Reporting (NCSR) again held the Asia Sustainability Report Rating (ASRRAT) 2020. The event in the... View Article

  • Program

    GRI Standards Certified Training

    The Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) is a non-governmental organization that develops and disseminates globally applicable voluntary Sustainability Reporting Guidelines. These guidelines has been developed through a multi-stakeholder process that incorporates the active participation of business, accountancy, investment, human rights, research and labour organizations from around the world.

    About NCSR

    NCSR in Brief

    NCSR is the first independent organization to develop sustainability reporting in Indonesia and the first organization to introduce the term “sustainability report” in Indonesia.

    Learn more

    National Center for Sustainability Reporting
    Buncit Town House Kav. 4
    Jl. Haji Sa'abun Taman Margasatwa
    Jakarta Selatan 12540
    Tel : +62 21 782 3524
    Fax: +62 21 782 3523

    ncsr.id
    ncsr_id
    ncsrindonesia
    National Center for Sustainability Reporting
     
    Need Help? Chat with us